Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Gerald Therrien's avatar

wow, what a tour de force.

And thank you for educating me on Madame Sun Yat-sen.

That clears up so much.

Keep singing!

Expand full comment
Jonathan's avatar

I want to say thank you for this comprehensive breakdown of this history. I'm still learning about the history of these regions, as I enjoy and am a student of history, and I appreciate the work folks like you, your husband, as well as Berletic at New Atlas does. I learned a great deal here and will read more. I even picked up the book you mentioned written by the early leader Sun who stepped down to maintain the peace. Nobody knows or even mentions this history in the West, yet it is important in how China should be viewed properly. I use to believe China was this all encompassing evil looking to destroy America in some universal struggle of good versus evil that is constantly messaged here in America. Yet my curiosity and questionings brought me here because that bizarre and sacrosanct version of reality is omnipresent in America and the West.

I'm just a young guy that comes from Brooklyn, NY. A black guy living in the West. I'm American, and frankly, it bothers me greatly with how far gone this nation is. I'd probably be considered a person on the Right out here, but this subject, and frankly foreign policy and history, is a disaster not just on the Right but throughout the country. I can't even discuss this history in right wing circles because they've gulped down propaganda for so long. Where they should have serious people like you and Matthew on for serious discussions, which would undoubtedly contradict alot of criminally incorrect and undercovered information, we get rehashings of state department versions of current and past events without any introspection or critical thinking.(ie; Russia is evil; Putin is the devil; Cold War forever; China is evil as they hold slaves, and other such bizarre messaging)

I write all this to say what people like you do is bastion of peace for me in what is an insanely corrupt West and America. I question greatly even my own circles, many of them good people, who don't even want to entertain this information. This is where I learn by myself and hope to make a difference where I can with the information I have. Things may be dark, but the truth remains a source of light and hope to those who tell it and receive it.

Expand full comment
22 more comments...

No posts